Hewitt Says We’re More Engaged in Selecting Our Benefits

by Clive Riddle, April 2, 2010

Hewitt Associates this week released data indicating that employees in 2009 were more engaged in selected their health benefits than in previous years. That being said, Hewitt concluded their choices weren’t all that different than before, they were just more involved in the process.

Here’s some of what Hewitt had to report on the matter: “Hewitt's analysis of 6 million U.S. workers, for whom Hewitt managed benefits enrollment in the fall of 2009, revealed the highest number of active enrollees since Hewitt began tracking the data in 2003. Nearly half (45 percent) of employees actively chose their benefits for 2010 instead of passively defaulting into the same coverage or no coverage at all. This is up significantly from the 2009 open enrollment period, where just 39 percent of employees actively enrolled. Despite employees taking a more active role in selecting their benefits, Hewitt's data shows very few workers enrolled in different health insurance plans.”

So what plans are employees enrolling in? Here’s a data table Hewitt shared indicating enrollment by plan type for the past three years (note that the survey involves large employers):

Enrollment by Plan Type

Open Enrollment Year	EPO	HMO	POS	PPO	Indemnity	HDHP
2008	1%	17%	11%	31%	15%	20%
2009	1%	17%	5%	34%	11%	18%
2010	1%	14%	8%	35%	13%	18%

So what does Hewitt make of all this? Sara Taylor, Hewitt’s Health and Welfare Strategy Leader tells us: "Employee inertia continues to play a large role in enrollment decisions—it's encouraging to see that people are more engaged in assessing their benefits, but that doesn't mean they are necessarily making different choices. If employers want workers to make different elections, they might need to adopt a more aggressive approach—whether it's changing or reducing plan options or offering plans with widely differing price points."